in this day and age of music being at the forefront of worship (especially the rock and/or roll variety), the question of guitar solos inevitably comes up. some people think that the guitar solo has absolutely no place in a worship setting, while others would absolutely love to hear it. while i’m not sure i have any definitive answers i do have several points i think you should consider when thinking through this question. i recently had a discussion with my friend travis about this very topic, and here are some of the things we discussed (not in particular order of importance, just in the order that we thought through things…in fact i think some of the more revolutionary thoughts are farther down the list):
1. setting.
where is the worship service/music taking place? is this a big conference or convention where music is the main focuse of what is happening? is this a sunday morning service (where time schedules need to be more closely followed)?
2. expectations of the audience.
is your audience used to guitar solos? if they are what is their reaction to them? would your audience tune out the music portion of the worship because of this? is the audience following you “into the moment” to where the solo/instrumental wouldn’t be the focus but an extended time of worship and reflection upon the words they have just sung?
3. art forms and giftedness.
i think this is my personal favorite consideration. travis actually brought this point up so thanks to him for that. as christians, one of our most important things in life is to appreciate and make use of the gifts and talents that God has given us. often in worship services we celebrate the beauty of dance, painting, a beautiful vocal solo, etc. i know that for myself i have never stopped to consider guitar solos to be in the same vain. why do i not consider a guitar solo in a worship setting as a person using his or her giftedness as an act of worship. during a dance, i have never stopped to think, why are we focusing on this instead of God? it’s because i’m focused on the gift that God has blessed that person with.
i also find it interesting that we will often have instrumentals played by an orchestra or bell choir or other ensemble and this never receives the same negative response as does a solo? why is this any different?
if worship is indeed not solely just a music service like we say it is. if worship is in fact the whole service and our whole lives. then i would contend that a guitar solo is no different than a skit or a painting or a solo sung.
4. purpose.
on the other side of the coin, we should consider the purpose of the solo. the purpose should never be to look at the guitar player and be envious or to glorify that person and their skills. the purpose (if solos are used) as i see it should be one of a few things. either we can glorify God for the ability he has placed within that person. secondly, if the instrumental section is used as an extension of worship for people to sing the words on their heart, or to reflect on the words they have just sung; then this i think is a perfectly acceptable purpose for using a solo. another purpose (and i’m sure there are more) could be for a time of dancing, jumping, and celebrating. for example, i’m currently working for a ministry called ”christ in youth” where i help lead worship for middle schoolers. during the song “break free” there is a section where we have a musical breakdown for everyone to dance around and have fun and celebrate their freedom in christ.
5. heart.
what is the heart with which the solo is done? how does the worship leader set up the moment? does the musician walk up to the front of the stage so everyone can see him or her? or does that person worship in that moment? this all comes back to the idea that everyone on stage should be worshiping as they play rather than merely “performing.”
well thanks for reading through this. it certainly can be a very delicate matter in any church, convention, retreat, etc. these are just the thoughts that travis and i came up with. i’m sure you have many more. i would love to hear them. i would love to continue having this conversation and thinking through the possibilities.
again, i do not think this is a black or white. i think the question could have different answers in different settings. it’s up to you as a worship leader, or planner, or whatever role you have to consider these points and more.
thanks for checking in!
until next time, go for a nice run. maybe you’ll have some profound thoughts.