one of the biggest complaints i hear from worship ministers is this: “it looked like nobody was singing today.”
my usual response is, “well that’s probably because they weren’t.”
this astounding phenomenon happens for many reasons. for a few blogs we will examine some of these.
today’s heinous reason for noticing the “no-singers”: the song leader has pitched the song in a terrible key. this is a problem taking our churches and conventions and retreats and whatever else by storm (or more accurately, taking them by ”quiet”).
i was fortunate enough to have a lady at the church i worked at in tennessee (the one and only becky swain), who came to me early in my ministry and said, “isaac, i couldn’t sing a single song today. they were all too low or too high.” and so from then on, every week becky would tell me if the songs were pitched okay that week, and it greatly benefitted the singing of our church.
some of the problems:
#1. we have men blindly picking songs for groups mostly made up of women singers. it’s just a fact of life, women are much more likely to sing than men. yet most of our song leaders are men, who don’t have much of a clue what’s a comfortable range for a woman to sing in. if you are a male and a song/worship leader; i encourage you to find a woman to bounce ideas off of. this woman should NOT be an amazing singer. you just want your average, run of the mill, i-sing-at-church woman. play something for her and ask if it’s comfortable to sing along with.
#2. many of these men worship leaders (and women as well) have this notion that they need to show off their pipes. again, we know you are a good singer from that solo you did during offering last week. however, this time is about congregational singing and everyone doing it together. don’t sing at the top of your range just to prove you can do it. sing in a range that johnny q. churchgoer feels comfortable vocalizing.
#3. there aren’t enough women song leaders. what a revelation this could be. let’s just eliminate the middle (wo)man from problem #1 and have women be the song leaders. they sure do know what key they can sing in and don’t have to ask anyone. however if you are a woman worship leader, i encourage you to find a man to bounce ideas off of about where to pitch a song.
#4. we have too many chris tomlin wannabees. chris tomlin can get up. plain and simple. the dude can sing high. we’re talking bono range. there is absolutely no point in singing songs congregationally in the same key they are recorded in, unless it’s already manageable. chris tomlin and all these other guys do that on their albums because they can and that’s what they get paid to travel around the world and do. so if you want people to sing along, i suggest you don’t try and do “indescribable” in the key of “B” as it’s recorded. you probably want to bring it down to “G”.
#5. we always have full band music. have an acoustic week. people have to sing then. during a full-out blaring music set no one knows if the voices are missing. turn the music down and listen. then people will sing. no more wondering what happened to the voices.
all right! we are on are way to no more singless sundays or wednesdays or whenever it is that you gather. i know you want people to sing along. so think through what key you will play and sing your songs in the next time you lead a worship service. or better yet encourage your church’s music leader to think about it (or read this post).
thanks for checkin’ in.
until next time, go learn 5 spanish words.